expo63: (smoke ladder 1)

What is this?

Chapter XXXVIII (1914)
becomes Chapter XXXVII in the published novel (1971)

As he wandered about, the keeper whom he had reprimanded in the early morning came up to him, and enquired whether he would shoot to morrow. Obviously he wouldn’t, since to morrow was the match, but the question had been asked to pave the way for an apology. “I sure I’m very sorry I failed to give you and Mr London, sir, full satisfaction sir,” was the form “I tried to do my best.” Maurice, no longer vindictive said “All right, Scudder,” though to himself he said “He wants to make sure of a tip from me when I do go: a servant doesn’t apologise otherwise.” This Scudder was an importation – part of the larger life that had come to Penge with Anne. They had not liked him much out shooting: he was smart and efficient, but had bossed Maurice rather and pulled him about by the elbow: now he implied he had refused five bob because he had not done enough to deserve it. “It’s for us to settle what they deserve,” Maurice thought, “and he’d no scruples over London’s ten, come!” He smiled slightly: the servant responded, his bright eyes shining in the dusk, and his teeth gleaming under a clipped but boyish moustache. Maurice went in.

Reconstructed from
p. 160 (Maurice, Chapter XXXVII)
and pp. 250–1 (notes to Chapter XXXVII) in

E. M. Forster (1999) Maurice: The Abinger Edition, edited by Philip Gardner (London: Andre Deutsch)


Gardner (1999: p.250): ‘CHAPTER XXXVII. This is Ch. XXXVIII in 1914. There are many revisions, all in Forster’s hand, visible in the 1914 text of this chapter, which consists of five typescript pages … and four … entirely in Forster’s early hand. Further revisions are registered by the 1932 text, which essentially provides he chapter as printed in 1971 and here [the 1999 Abinger Edition]. Some of these revisions date from the 1950s, and are so indicated.’

Maurice 1914 Extract 2

expo63: (smoke ladder 1)
kristinaa1 just asked me about this in my earlier post/thread over on mr_edna_may. My reply came out really long, so I'm re-posting it here in case anyone else feels like joining in/debating this:

In the movie scudder tells Maurice that he knows about him and Clive. I don't get how he could know though. Is it explained in the book? Or do we infer that scudder just has Really good gaydar?

There's a short answer – and a lo-oo-ong answer:

Read more... )
expo63: (Default)
An update to my earlier post/promise over at the mr_edna_may comm

Read more... )

expo63: (Default)
Originally posted at LJ gravesdiggers and LJ mr_edna_may, but I've copied this to my LJ to help me keep tabs on it.

For anyone who wants to read Forster's original Epilogue to Maurice, you can do so for free on LJ (without buying the Abinger edition of the novel, which MHiH was recommending). devo79 did some very thorough research for two Maurice fics she posted on LJ in 2007, including posting Forster's whole Epilogue here: http://devo79.livejournal.com/4001.html

If anyone does buy the Abinger edition and it gives any detail about the pre-published drafts of Maurice and differences from the 1971 published novel, please get in touch.  I just found out very recently that Forster added the boathouse happy ending very late on. He originally had Alec actually emigrate to Argentina (*sobs uncontrollably*), and even at one point wrote (quite clunky) dialogue in which Maurice refuses to go to the hotel with Alec (*sob sob sob*). So if the Abinger edition adds anything significant I need to know. It's a long shot, but thanks!

Comments @ mr_edna_may
Comments @ gravesdiggers

May 2012



RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Sep. 24th, 2017 07:27 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios